Is an Uber a Taxi?

Written by: The Institute of Certified bookkeepers

Is an Uber a Taxi?

Yes but No!

The Current Law says – No an Uber is NOT a Taxi

ATO position on ride-sourcing and the FBT taxi travel exemption

We recently confirmed our existing view that the taxi travel exemption from FBT does not extend to ride-sourcing vehicles like Uber. Ride-sourcing vehicles do not meet this taxi travel exemption even though the Federal Court in Uber BV v Commissioner of Taxation [2017] FCA 110 confirmed that use of a ride-sourcing vehicle counts as ‘taxi travel’ for GST purposes.

This is because, for FBT purposes, the taxi travel exemption is only available to trips in a ‘taxi’, which the FBT law defines as a ‘motor vehicle that is licensed to operate as a taxi’. Ride-sourcing vehicles do not have such a license. For more information, read the ATO’s FBT Guide for Employers.

Impact of this position on FBT and the use of ride-sourcing vehicles

The taxi travel exemption most commonly arises when an employer provides their employee the use of a taxi for a private purpose (such as a trip home from work when an employee is unwell). If an employer instead offers the use of a ride-sourcing vehicle for these purposes, they may incur a liability for FBT.

However, if an employer pays for their employee to use a ride-sourcing vehicle for work purposes, such as transport between two workplaces, they will not have an FBT liability if the expenditure would be deductible by the employee.

Further, if an employer pays for an employee’s travel in a ride-source vehicle only once or twice a year on an ad hoc basis, and the value of the benefit is less than $300, then such travel may be exempt from FBT as a minor benefit.

New Law as proposed to Parliament says Yes

Treasury has released an exposure draft of a Miscellaneous Amendments Bill for community feedback by 27 September 2019. The exposure draft proposes to make amendments to the Fringe Benefits Tax Assessment Act 1986 in relation to the FBT taxi travel exemption.

According to the draft explanatory memorandum, these amendments propose to replace references to a ‘taxi’ with ‘a car used for taxi travel (other than a limousine)’. It notes that this change is ‘a result of ride sharing providers entering into the market, making it difficult to administer the current meaning of ‘licensed to operate as a taxi’
The term ‘taxi travel’ is proposed to be defined as having the same meaning as in the GST legislation.

So what do we do now?

Current law says you must record uber like trips from work to home separately from taxi trips because the FBT treatment is different.

The consultation on the proposed law change concludes 27 September and will then be considered by Parliament.

Previous Articles

If you enjoyed this article and would like to see others, then click on the link below.

Accountability BAS and Bookkeeping Services provide professional bookkeeping and BAS services to businesses in most Australian states.

What our clients say about us…

“I had the pleasure of being introduced to ABBS through Jo Bacon the WA representative. The professional service.  I have received has been so essential in assisting me with my new business, I am so grateful for the expertise, professionalism and excellent customer service I have experienced.” Marion B

“Thanks to Steve Cocks from ABBS we managed to get all the books up to date and in no time, … and that took the weight off my shoulders so I could focus on developing my business and moving forward in a more organized and structured way, keeping on top of things every month which makes life much easier.”  Elisabeth G

“As an ex-bookkeeper, I’m pretty fussy about how I like things done and I’ve found Caran from ABBS to be a pleasure to work with. She’s competent and efficient and now that I have her helping me with the bookkeeping for my business, I wouldn’t be without her.”  Sandy T

    “As a sole director of a regional law firm,  I’m very conscious of the need to have the proper business support, particularly in the areas of bookkeeping and trust accounting. Since I outsourced those components of my business to ABBS, I feel as if these vital components of my business are in expert hands and I can relax knowing that it is all being done properly , efficiently and legally.  Rob’s expertise with running a business including his insight with managing employees, his ready availability for a discussion at any time on any business matter, his advice and support, have been absolutely invaluable to CastleGate Law.  In addition, Janice from ABBS looks after my trust accounting through Leap with equal efficiency and expertise – she and Rob make a great team for any law firm.  Not only do I feel like I’m sharing the considerable burden of running a law firm, but I feel like in Rob I have someone on my side as a business owner, because of his implicit understanding of business matters, his encouragement and support. For all these reasons I cannot recommend ABBS highly enough as additions to any law firm or business partner. ”  Kate R